-
0
Question: What is the wavefunction? Is it a sea of probability of where the particle could lie? If so, are particles always found at the most probabilistic location in terms of the wavefunction? Which particles are the most predictable?
- Keywords:
-
Joel Goldstein answered on 24 Feb 2023: last edited 24 Feb 2023 5:35 pm
Simple (but infuriating answer): no-one knows what the wavefunction really is, and hence what quantum mechanics really means.
In classical physics we describe a physical system as a bunch of particles, with definite position and velocity at any given time. We intuitively know what “position” and “velocity” mean, and the laws of classical physics tell us how they evolve with time.
In quantum mechanics we describe a physical system by the wavefunction, and we have equations that tell us how it evolves in time. Unfortunately, the wavefunction does not seem to have an intuitive meaning. The most we can say is that when we square the value of the wavefunction we get the probability of a particular occurence. For example, if we prepare a large number of particles with a wavefunction that is 0.6x(spin up) + 0.8x(spin down) and then measure the spin of each particle, we would find that 36% of the time it is up and 64% it is down.
Figuring out what this tells us about the nature of the universe is something that has been hotly debated for a century by physicists, philosophers and Oscar-nominated films.
-
Benjamin Rienacker answered on 24 Feb 2023:
I’d say the real physics problem lies in the second part of the question: […] where the particle could lie. While the mathematics of quantum mechanics, and also the wavefunction, is a tool for calculating probablities for where a statistical relevant number of particles will or will not be detected, it actually does not describe the single particle. Even worse, we do not really know what a particle is. We know some properties and behavior in certain situations, but we do not have any idea how to describe a “single particle” moving through a double-slit and interfering with itself, but then being detected as a particle and not a wave. The same problematic oocurs in the less simple regions of particle physics. The one finding a single conclusive theory that explains the wave-like behavior in propagation and the localized detection of particles will probably have found a new field of physics, so to speak.
Related Questions
Hi, In the pursuit of unraveling the mysteries at the quantum level, how do you envision the integration of emerging
Particle Physics question: Why can we not create a nucleus for an atom with greater than 118 protons? Strong nuclear
Where did the name ‘beauty quark’ come from? What sets it apart from other fundamental particles?
How did you discover particles in the standard model (how do you measure a particle's spin/mass) and is there a limit
What is the use in trying to create antimatter? Accelerating particles and causing collisions to produce antimatter
Latest Questions
-
Hi, In the pursuit of unraveling the mysteries at the quantum level, how do you envision the integration of emerging
-
How do you keep the inside of the particle accelerator clean as the images attached show that the scientists are
-
How long did it take to build the LHC?
-
when do you think this project will be completed on a gobal scale ?
-
what are some fond memories and or once in a lifetime experiences that have stuck with you that were as a result of
-
How difficult was university compared to High School?
-
What is your personal opinion on the gravtion. Do you think it is something we will find and if so when? Do you know of
-
Like in mathematics are there Axioms of physics from which everything is built on and are undeniably true but yet
-
Particle Physics question: Why can we not create a nucleus for an atom with greater than 118 protons? Strong nuclear (1 Comment)
-
On a scale of 1 to 10 rate your job difficulty with 1 being easy and fun, 5 being balanced and 10 being extremely work
Latest Comments
-
Particle Physics question: Why can we not create a nucleus for an atom with greater than 118 protons? Strong nuclear (1 comment)
-
How many proton collisions are there per second in the LHCb experiment? (1 comment)
-
How do you conceptualise/comprehend empty space such as the empty space between atoms. What kind of properties does (1 comment)
-
Are you looking forward to the CERN Zone? Students will be able to send questions (like this!), and there will be live (1 comment)
-
Could there be a whole other set such as dark energy variations of both matter and antimatter? (1 comment)
Comments