-
0
Question: Particle Physics question: Why can we not create a nucleus for an atom with greater than 118 protons? Strong nuclear force only has a range of a few fm range however while the two protons on opposite ends of the nucleus may not experience attraction the one on the far end would surely experience attraction to the next nucleon and the next until the chain reaches the other side.
-
Jonathan Edward Davies answered on 12 Oct 2023:
So the simple answer is that some nuclei are more “tightly” bound than others, due to a variety of effects which I explain a bit more below. This means that it can be energetically more favorable to be radioactively decay into another element. What I mean is things always want to minimise their energy. It turns out that lead is the most stable of these and ultimately this is why things like Uranium will decay into other elements and why you can create a bomb (release a lot of energy) by either splitting apart heavy nuclei (fission) or fusing together lighter ones (fusion).
There’s a good graph demonstrating this here:
https://www.britannica.com/science/nuclear-binding-energy
Binding energy per nucleon measures how “tightly bound” a nucleus and energetically we want to maximise this because binding energy is essentially “negative energy”- energy that you have to add to pull apart the nucleus. Really in nuclear physics we think about the “nuclear” force rather than the strong force which acts between the quarks inside the protons or neutrons and is diluted and screened somewhat by the time we get to the dimensions of the nucleus.
There are a number of contributions to this overall binding energy. There is a surface tension effect and is proportional to the number of nucleons that are situated on the nuclear surface- it is largest for light nuclei. There is electrostatic repulsion between the positively charged protons- this becomes more important as the number of protons increases. There is a symmetry correction term taking into account that generally the most stable arrangement has equal numbers of protons and neutrons (because the n–p interaction in a nucleus is stronger than either the n−n or p−p interaction). There’s also a final term which depends on whether there are even or odd numbers of protons or neutrons. I believe the effect of nuclear spins of the protons and neutrons will feature in these last terms somewhere.
Sorry, maybe a bit of a technical answer to your question but you can maybe see that the situation is quite complicated, with lots of effects going on, and we can’t solve this system exactly.
-
Related Questions
How do you conceptualise/comprehend empty space such as the empty space between atoms. What kind of properties does
Where did the name ‘beauty quark’ come from? What sets it apart from other fundamental particles?
What A levels will I need to do something similar to this?
What is the wavefunction? Is it a sea of probability of where the particle could lie? If so, are particles always found
Is the physics industry a “male-dominated” workplace and if so is there any pressure ?
How did you discover particles in the standard model (how do you measure a particle's spin/mass) and is there a limit
What is the use in trying to create antimatter? Accelerating particles and causing collisions to produce antimatter
Latest Questions
-
How difficult was university compared to High School?
-
What is your personal opinion on the gravtion. Do you think it is something we will find and if so when? Do you know of
-
Like in mathematics are there Axioms of physics from which everything is built on and are undeniably true but yet
-
Particle Physics question: Why can we not create a nucleus for an atom with greater than 118 protons? Strong nuclear (1 Comment)
-
On a scale of 1 to 10 rate your job difficulty with 1 being easy and fun, 5 being balanced and 10 being extremely work
-
How many proton collisions are there per second in the LHCb experiment? (1 Comment)
-
How do you conceptualise/comprehend empty space such as the empty space between atoms. What kind of properties does (1 Comment)
-
do you get to travel the world?
-
What do you look for in a personal statement? And what can I do to improve my chances of getting into the uni of my
-
Is it possible a black hole could form from the work you are doing?
Latest Comments
-
Particle Physics question: Why can we not create a nucleus for an atom with greater than 118 protons? Strong nuclear (1 comment)
-
How many proton collisions are there per second in the LHCb experiment? (1 comment)
-
How do you conceptualise/comprehend empty space such as the empty space between atoms. What kind of properties does (1 comment)
-
Are you looking forward to the CERN Zone? Students will be able to send questions (like this!), and there will be live (1 comment)
-
Could there be a whole other set such as dark energy variations of both matter and antimatter? (1 comment)
Comments
AlfieC commented on :
thanks for the explanation. cleared it up a lot.